Cosby big winner in Katherine McKee’s defamation lawsuit, but drama ain’t over

Bill Cosby

Bill Cosby comes out on top in defamation lawsuit.

Cosby defamation lawsuit kicked out.

Mass Appeal Wire Reports

BOSTON, Ma. — More than 50 women have accused Bill Cosby of sticking his JELL-O pudding pop where it doesn’t belong. But, so far, those allegations aren’t sticking. On Thursday, U.S. District Court Judge Mark Mastroianna threw out Katherine McKee’s defamation lawsuit against the 79-year-old comedian on the grounds of lack of evidence. “An accused person cannot be foreclosed, during their responsive navigation, from considering the issuance of a simple and unequivocal denial — free from overall defamatory triggers or contextual themes,” Mastroianna wrote in the decision. “Such a situation would be inconsistent with basic First Amendment principles.”

McKee, if you recall, is an actress who claims Cosby raped her in 1974. Her sexual assault allegation first appeared in the New York Daily News three years ago. Shortly after the article was published, Cosby’s lawyer sent the newspaper a denial letter seeking a retraction.

McKee then sued Cosby a year later (in 2015) for defamation. She asked the court for monetary and punitive damages. But she won’t get a dime. Cosby’s reps are obviously elated with the decision.

“This is another in a line of recent developments vindicating Mr. Cosby’s right to defend himself in the face of an onslaught of unverified accusations,” said Cosby spokesperson Andrew Wyatt.

McKee plans to appeal the decision.

Do you think Cosby is innocent or guilty?

Share your thoughts below.

25 comments

  1. Bill Cosby’s Attorney is amazing

  2. Look why did it take this long to come forward these 50+ women are only looking for his money it’s very wrong but I do believe cosby is guilty of the 2004 assault why else did he pay her off as for the 1960s and 70s it’s hard to know sure back then these women were probably throwing themselves at him if they didn’t trust him they could left the room

  3. fucken lying scums

  4. I'm so fucking petty

    His actions soiled his reputation for life

  5. Kathryn Dorsey

    True. I don’t know if I believe all these women who say they got raped back in the 60’s/70’s/80’s. Plus, Bill is a black man. Even the 2004 assault sounds shady. She said Bill was hitting on her and she didn’t like him BUT she did later go to his room for a drink and took a pill from him. That is strange

  6. What,…you mean that we don’t just take these gold diggers,….sorry,…..upstanding women’s word for it.
    This justice system is reprehensible for not allowing these women s claims to be the verdict without
    trial. And how dare he sue known whores,…sorry women of integrity, when they lie,….sorry, tell their truth
    to relieve him of his fortune.
    I’m heading straight back to feminist HQ to report this outrage.

  7. So….it took them 40 years to remember this hey…

  8. Ingemar Kenyatta

    This is amazing. I started off CERTAIN that Cosby HAD TO have done it. After the evidence has been presented from both sides, I found myself blown away. The guy doesn’t appear to have done anything actually against the law.

  9. it’s a load of shit! I’m 100 percent convinced they are just after money.. half of the women accusing him have a criminal history of theft fraud bullshit ting through their teeth!! and been in prison. why any judge would take them seriously blows my mind.. I support bill cosby 100 percent and believe he is innocent.. I hope it goes in his favour.

  10. Bill Cosby is the original ‘Dindu Nuffin’.

  11. DeplorableJoker

    If you get raped and don’t tell police the next day or week then that’s your fault. The fuck you waiting 40 years, bitch get lost you ain’t getting no money bitch.

  12. tattooedpain29

    Bill is innocent!!!!!

  13. tattooedpain29 I believe so.. I really do.. he may have played up a little in his younger days, but hey! who doesn’t. I don’t think it’s to the extent these women are making out.. I find it strange how one comes out after 40years; then all of a sudden other women come out from years ago.. I’m convinced they are just jumping on the band wagon hoping to get his money.. idiot bitches!!

  14. I love how all of the Black commenters are in total denial, unwilling or unable to accept that a monumental Black icon of Cosby’s stature is capable of being a serial rapist. SO many racist Blacks out here showing their true ugliness calling this woman all sorts of insulting names. This is the nature of psychopaths, people. They SPECIALIZE in being charismatic and charming on the surface, to conceal the monsters that lurk beneath the surface. They know they must wear the mask of sanity and charm to get ahead in life. As soon as they are behind closed doors with an unsuspecting or vulnerable victim, the Mr. Hyde personality comes out, and is only seen by those who they prey upon. You naysayers are only able to see the finely crafted face of Cliff Huxtable. COsby is obviously a genius sociopath. He fooled the fukking world. Well, karma is a bitch, and now, in the twilight of his life, he is going to watch his empire crumble before his very eyes. A fitting punishment. Cosby is finished. This is the true hand of God at work here. Truth will out. Always. You may hide your misdeeds from the eyes of men, but you can never hide them from the eyes of God.

  15. MinasPraSempre

    I love Bill Cosby, and am not God to judge…but ALL the women that are coming out, have very similar stories! They were all young, all VERY good looking, all alleged pretty much the same exact thing (he “drugged them out, etc…”). I mean, I believe that by now, it’d be very hard to prove, none the less…I think it happened! It’s just like the Kennedys; we didn’t want to believe all the allegations but it was true!

  16. The raping and the roofies and the pudding pops

  17. Van Rathbun Jr.

    Everybody needs to stop assuming that he is guilty before he is convicted. Innocent before proven guilty, remember???

  18. False accusers deserve to be raped and shit on.

  19. I had a dream/ nightmare last week that Bill drugged me? I can’t remember anything after that. I think Lionel Richie was there too.

  20. he’s innocent

  21. Lower Middle Class Patriots

    I am going to track this rapist down and beat him to death!!!

  22. I’m glad Cosby never got arrested fuck all y’all women hope y’all get raped next stupid bitches.

  23. THESE WOMEN WENT INTO HIS HOTEL ROOM WITH HIM WILLINGLY AFTTER A NIGHT OF PARTYING IN THE 70’S WHERE IT IS WELL DOCUMENTED THAT PEOPLE RECREATIONALLY USED GHB (THE NOW DATERAPE DRUG) AS A RECREATIONAL DRUG TO HELP COME DOWN AFTER SNORTING LOTS OF COKE. THEY ADMITTED THAT THEY WENT INTO HIS ROOM WILLINGLY KNOWING HE WAS MARRIED.

    TO DO WHAT IN HIS ROOM? LOOK AT THE FURNITURE? GIVE ME A BREAK. COSBY IS INOCCENT AND THESE HOES WHeRE TOTALLY Down to Fuck AT THE TIME….. end rant

  24. fucking sex maniac…

  25. wouldyoulikeapickle

    I can’t believe some of these comments. It’s no wonder victims of rape don’t come the fuck forward. I would take any amount of money over having the world tell me I’m a lying, money hungry slut. If your first instinct is to victim blame than you’re a real piece of shit. This is what happens with a celebrity imagine someone accusing your best friend of rape. You’d defend them to the death? My god. The world we live in. You’ve got pastors and loved celebrities RAPING and MOLESTING people and all people can say is they are all LIARS. Society is so fucked.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*